College Review Guidelines

Q: Can a college pay to remove a negative review?

No. Colleges cannot purchase review removal or pay to improve a public grade. Content may be reviewed when a legitimate privacy, factual, legal or guideline concern is raised.

CampusGrader Review Standards

Share an Honest College Experience That Helps Future Students

CampusGrader welcomes thoughtful reviews from students and alumni. These guidelines explain what makes a useful review, what content is not allowed, and how submissions are moderated before affecting public ratings.

Submit a College Review How Grades Work

Before you submit

Three Standards Every Review Should Meet

Describe your own experience

Review the college based on what you personally observed or experienced.

Be specific and constructive

Explain what worked, what did not, and why it mattered.

Protect personal information

Do not publish private contact details or identifying information about individuals.

Reviews Are Moderated New submissions remain pending until reviewed against these guidelines.

Approved Reviews Only Pending reviews never affect public grades, ratings, rankings or counts.

Positive and Negative Welcome Reviews do not need to be favorable, but they must remain honest and constructive.

Purpose of these guidelines

Help Students Share Useful Experiences Without Causing Harm

CampusGrader is designed to capture honest college experiences while maintaining standards for relevance, fairness, privacy and constructive participation.

The central standard

Review the College Experience, Not Individual People

A CampusGrader review should help future students understand the academic, residential, financial, social and career-related experience of attending a college.

Reviews may describe interactions with offices, departments, services or general campus systems, but they should not become personal attacks against professors, students, employees or other identifiable individuals.

Strong reviews explain the circumstances, provide context and make clear that the submission reflects the reviewer’s own experience.

What CampusGrader accepts

Honest Experiences With Clear Context

A review can be positive, negative or mixed. Approval depends on the quality and appropriateness of the content, not the rating given.

✓

Firsthand experience The review reflects what the contributor personally experienced.

✓

Relevant college information The content relates to the institution and its student experience.

✓

Respectful language Criticism is allowed without harassment, threats or abuse.

✓

Balanced detail Specific examples are more useful than unsupported claims.

Who may submit a review

Reviews Should Come From People With Direct College Experience

CampusGrader is intended for contributors who can speak from personal knowledge of the institution they are reviewing.

Current Students

Enrolled students may review their current experience with classes, housing, support services, campus life, cost and career resources.

Alumni and Former Students

Graduates and former students may share experiences from the time they attended, while recognizing that policies and services may have changed.

Transfer and Recently Departed Students

Students who transferred or recently left may review the portion of the college experience they personally completed.

Writing a useful review

Be Specific, Fair and Focused on the Student Experience

The most helpful reviews explain both the rating and the circumstances behind it.

Helpful review practices

What Strengthens a Review

✓

Explain the rating

Describe why you selected a particular score instead of leaving the rating unexplained.

✓

Include useful examples

Mention the type of class, service, housing situation or campus experience involved.

✓

Acknowledge mixed experiences

It is acceptable to describe both positive and negative aspects of the same college.

✓

Use your own words

Submit original content rather than copied text or repeated promotional language.

Review practices to avoid

What Weakens or Disqualifies a Review

Unsupported accusations

Do not present speculation, rumor or unverified claims as established fact.

Personal attacks

Do not insult, threaten, shame or target identifiable people.

Unrelated complaints

Content must remain connected to the college and the student experience.

Repeated or coordinated submissions

Do not submit duplicate reviews or organize submissions to manipulate a college’s rating.

The six CampusGrader categories

Rate Each Part of the College Experience Thoughtfully

Consider what you personally experienced within each category rather than allowing one strong or weak area to determine every score.

Academics

Consider teaching quality, course access, academic expectations, advising and learning resources.

Housing & Dining

Consider residence halls, maintenance, food quality, dining options and everyday campus living.

Safety & Support

Consider campus safety, accessibility, counseling, student support and responsiveness when problems arise.

Cost & Value

Consider tuition, fees, financial pressure, available resources and the value received for the cost.

Campus Life

Consider student organizations, campus culture, activities, belonging and social opportunities.

Career Support

Consider internships, career advising, employer access, alumni connections and preparation for life after college.

Content that is not allowed

Reviews May Be Rejected or Removed for Guideline Violations

CampusGrader may decline, edit for safety, or remove content that violates platform standards or creates unnecessary risk.

Threats or Harassment

Threatening, intimidating, abusive or targeted harassing language is not permitted.

Private Personal Information

Do not publish phone numbers, addresses, private email addresses, student records or other sensitive identifying information.

Discriminatory or Hateful Content

Content attacking people based on protected or personal characteristics is not accepted.

False Representation

Do not impersonate another person, falsely claim attendance or misrepresent your connection to the college.

Promotional or Commercial Content

Reviews may not be used for advertising, recruiting, solicitation or unrelated promotion.

Rating Manipulation

Duplicate, incentivized, coordinated or automated submissions intended to change a college’s public grade are prohibited.

Copied or Unoriginal Reviews

Reviews copied from another person, platform, article or marketing source may be rejected.

Graphic or Explicit Material

Unnecessary graphic, sexually explicit or deeply disturbing content may be removed or declined.

Content Unrelated to the College

Submissions must remain focused on the institution and a genuine student experience.

Moderation and approval

A Submitted Review Does Not Immediately Affect Public Results

Every new review remains pending until it is approved. Pending submissions do not influence public star ratings, CampusGrader grades, category averages, rankings, comparisons or approved review counts.

Pending reviews remain private The review is excluded from public calculations while awaiting moderation.

Approval activates the review An approved review may then contribute to the college’s public rating and grade.

Rejection is based on standards A review may be declined because of content, relevance, authenticity or guideline concerns.

Approval is not an endorsement CampusGrader does not independently confirm every opinion or personal experience expressed by a reviewer.

Privacy, corrections and removal

Protect Yourself and Use the Reporting Process When Needed

Contributors and college representatives may contact CampusGrader about privacy concerns, factual profile corrections or content that may violate these guidelines.

Protect Your Privacy

Do not include information that could expose your private contact details, student records, login credentials or other sensitive personal information.

Read the Privacy Policy

Report Review Content

Contact CampusGrader when a published review may contain private information, harassment, false representation or another guideline concern.

Report a Review Concern

Request a Profile Correction

College representatives and visitors may report inaccurate factual details appearing on a published college profile.

Request a Correction

Integrity and eligibility

Reviews Must Be Independent, Authentic and Based on Direct Experience

CampusGrader may reject reviews when the contributor lacks firsthand experience, has an undisclosed conflict of interest or appears to be participating in a coordinated rating campaign.

One Review Per Person, Per College

Contributors should submit one review for each college they attended. An updated review may be considered when the contributor’s experience materially changes, such as after graduation, transfer or a substantial additional period of enrollment.

Conflicts Must Be Disclosed

Contributors should disclose employment, paid ambassador work, recruiting relationships, vendor relationships, promotional roles or other interests that could influence the review.

No Incentivized Reviews

Reviews submitted in exchange for money, gifts, discounts, academic benefits, employment benefits or another reward are not permitted unless CampusGrader specifically authorizes and clearly discloses the arrangement.

Employees and Representatives

College employees, contractors, agencies and official representatives should not submit reviews as ordinary students. Institutional concerns and factual corrections should be sent through the CampusGrader contact process.

Applicants and Parents

Applicants who did not attend and parents describing experiences they did not personally have should not submit student reviews. They may use the contact form to report factual profile concerns.

Authenticity Review

CampusGrader may request reasonable evidence of attendance or affiliation when authenticity concerns arise. Any information provided for verification should be handled in accordance with the Privacy Policy.

Possible moderation outcomes

What May Happen After a Review Is Submitted

Moderation decisions may depend on authenticity, relevance, privacy, safety, clarity and compliance with these guidelines.

Approved

The review becomes eligible to appear publicly and contribute to ratings, grades, rankings, comparisons and approved review counts.

Held for Review

The submission remains pending while additional authenticity, privacy or guideline concerns are evaluated.

Returned for Revision

CampusGrader may ask the contributor to remove personal information, clarify the experience or revise content before reconsideration.

Rejected

The review does not become public or affect any college rating, grade, ranking, comparison or approved review count.

Removed After Publication

A published review may be removed when a material violation, authenticity problem, privacy risk or legal concern is discovered.

Editing, removal and reconsideration

CampusGrader Protects Reviewer Meaning While Enforcing Standards

Limited moderation edits may be made for privacy, safety and formatting, but CampusGrader should not materially rewrite a reviewer’s opinion.

When Published Content May Be Removed

A negative opinion is not removed simply because a college disagrees with it. Removal may be considered when there is a material policy, authenticity, privacy, safety or legal concern.

Private or sensitive information The review exposes personal records, contact details or other information that should not be public.

Impersonation or false affiliation The contributor misrepresented attendance, identity or a connection to the institution.

Manipulation or coordinated activity The review was duplicated, incentivized, automated or submitted as part of an organized rating campaign.

Threats, harassment or serious abuse The content targets identifiable people or creates a meaningful safety concern.

Material fabrication or legal concern Credible information indicates that the review contains significant fabricated content or creates a legitimate legal issue.

Requests for Reconsideration

Reviewers and institutions may contact CampusGrader to request that a moderation or removal decision be reconsidered.

Provide clear supporting information Explain the concern and include relevant facts without submitting unnecessary private information.

Disagreement alone is not enough A college’s objection to a critical opinion does not automatically justify removal.

Decisions remain discretionary Publication, revision, rejection and removal decisions remain subject to CampusGrader’s moderation standards and judgment.

Context and severity matter CampusGrader may consider intent, repetition, potential harm, authenticity and the seriousness of the violation.

Effective and last updated: June 2026

CampusGrader may revise these guidelines as the platform, moderation systems and legal requirements develop. The version published on this page governs current review submissions and moderation decisions.

Frequently asked questions

Questions About College Review Moderation

Can I submit a negative college review?

Yes. Reviews may be positive, negative or mixed. Negative ratings are not rejected simply because they are critical. The review must still be firsthand, relevant, constructive and free from prohibited content.

Will my review affect the college immediately?

No. A new submission remains pending until approved. Pending reviews do not affect public star ratings, letter grades, category averages, rankings, comparisons or approved review counts.

Can I name a professor or another student?

Reviews should focus on the college experience rather than identifiable individuals. Avoid naming students, instructors or employees, especially when making critical or sensitive claims.

Can CampusGrader edit a submitted review?

CampusGrader may decline a review or make limited changes when needed to protect privacy, remove unsafe content, correct formatting or enforce platform standards. Material changes to the meaning of a review should be avoided.

Can a college pay to remove a negative review?

No. A college cannot purchase the removal of a review or pay to improve its public grade. Published content may be reviewed when a legitimate privacy, factual, legal or guideline concern is raised.

Does approval mean CampusGrader verified every statement?

No. Approval means the submission met the platform’s moderation standards at the time of review. Student reviews reflect individual experiences and should be considered alongside official college information and additional independent research.

Ready to contribute?

Share a Thoughtful Review of Your College Experience

Focus on what you personally experienced, explain your ratings and provide useful context for future students. Your submission will remain pending until approved.

Submit a College Review Browse College Profiles